05-23-2024, 01:50 PM
Warning! - Unpopular Opinion Ahead -
I personally believe no discussion board can continue to exist without a political discussion section. I believe this to be particularly true for any website which focuses any sort of conspiratorial, controversial or current events content. Many say politics ruined other sites (such as ATS); I disagree. In fact, I would posit the exact opposite; attempts by other websites to curtail, restrict or eliminate political discussion see a dramatic drop in participation across the entire site after which they languish in the sun, wither and drift off into irrelevancy. The facts are, politics occupy almost every single element of the news cycle today, and better than 90% of all the conspiratorial / controversial subjects of our time boil down to political in nature. Squashing this type of discussion and content only reduces overall contribution on a site such as this.
Case in point; there are a total of 6,722 posts (total, all forums) here on DI since its inception, compared to 22,539 posts in just the last 7 calendar days on ATS (104,841 posts in the past 30 days). Granted DI is relatively new compared to ATS, but the lion's share of active ATS members (key being 'active') are members here on DI. So, why the difference? Well, for one thing, politics often draws participants in, and they then engage on (10) other non-politics subjects while there. Exclude/prohibit politics, and many of those same individuals do not engage at all.
The other thing I think some are missing is the fact that other websites (ATS is only one example) didn't suddenly shift their focus to political activism, the world outside did. Between the MSM, social media and numerous other factors, the new paradigm is politics. Bottom line - politics is what people are talking about, regardless of any website focus. Failure to realize this is conscious failure to accept what is going on outside one's window. Politics IS the new conspiracy, and more importantly than ever; politics is the one area where seeking the "truth" and "denial of ignorance" is paramount to survival. Refusing to recognize this is burying one's head in the sand. All due respect to members who are interested in paranormal studies, UFO's and other supernatural phenomenon, these are indeed interesting subject areas, but in today's age these same topics alone are not sufficient to sustain a discussion forum today.
One only needs to look at the social media website 'reddit' to see the staggering proportion of political discussions in comparison to all other topics added together. Yes, policy makers and site creators can say...'well, we just don't want that here!'...and this is fine, but realize by saying this that you turn away large segments of your potential content providers and audience by doing so. If people are content living in this bubble, then this is fine also, but just know there is a very good probability that is all it will ever be, a bubble.
Again, I'm sure this opinion and editorial statement is a wildly unpopular one here, but I feel it is important to throw it out there in an effort to truly get to the "truth" we all so desperately wish to get to.
Very best regards, and thanks for your time.
FCD
I personally believe no discussion board can continue to exist without a political discussion section. I believe this to be particularly true for any website which focuses any sort of conspiratorial, controversial or current events content. Many say politics ruined other sites (such as ATS); I disagree. In fact, I would posit the exact opposite; attempts by other websites to curtail, restrict or eliminate political discussion see a dramatic drop in participation across the entire site after which they languish in the sun, wither and drift off into irrelevancy. The facts are, politics occupy almost every single element of the news cycle today, and better than 90% of all the conspiratorial / controversial subjects of our time boil down to political in nature. Squashing this type of discussion and content only reduces overall contribution on a site such as this.
Case in point; there are a total of 6,722 posts (total, all forums) here on DI since its inception, compared to 22,539 posts in just the last 7 calendar days on ATS (104,841 posts in the past 30 days). Granted DI is relatively new compared to ATS, but the lion's share of active ATS members (key being 'active') are members here on DI. So, why the difference? Well, for one thing, politics often draws participants in, and they then engage on (10) other non-politics subjects while there. Exclude/prohibit politics, and many of those same individuals do not engage at all.
The other thing I think some are missing is the fact that other websites (ATS is only one example) didn't suddenly shift their focus to political activism, the world outside did. Between the MSM, social media and numerous other factors, the new paradigm is politics. Bottom line - politics is what people are talking about, regardless of any website focus. Failure to realize this is conscious failure to accept what is going on outside one's window. Politics IS the new conspiracy, and more importantly than ever; politics is the one area where seeking the "truth" and "denial of ignorance" is paramount to survival. Refusing to recognize this is burying one's head in the sand. All due respect to members who are interested in paranormal studies, UFO's and other supernatural phenomenon, these are indeed interesting subject areas, but in today's age these same topics alone are not sufficient to sustain a discussion forum today.
One only needs to look at the social media website 'reddit' to see the staggering proportion of political discussions in comparison to all other topics added together. Yes, policy makers and site creators can say...'well, we just don't want that here!'...and this is fine, but realize by saying this that you turn away large segments of your potential content providers and audience by doing so. If people are content living in this bubble, then this is fine also, but just know there is a very good probability that is all it will ever be, a bubble.
Again, I'm sure this opinion and editorial statement is a wildly unpopular one here, but I feel it is important to throw it out there in an effort to truly get to the "truth" we all so desperately wish to get to.
Very best regards, and thanks for your time.
FCD
