Dead or on the lamb?

[l0st]

I call crap on that "Dry Drowning" or better known as Asphyxiation. My evidence is this story:
Man Found Alive at Bottom of the Sea 3 Days After Boat Sank: 'Total Shock' - Newsweek
So, this guy was in a small, very small, cabin for three days trapped in an air pocket and was still alive, but Lynch and friends were in much larger cabins and died due to lack of oxygen in less than a day? Were Lynch and friends gassed before the boat went down? 

Every time new "evidence" comes out the question of them being dead before the boat went under still lingers. I mean what next, they were unresponsive when the boat was shaking around for 9 minutes due to too much oxygen?

At this point, I honestly think they have absolutely no idea what happened and are simply making things up.